Model Reviews

It is generally considered best practice for an MPO to get an external review of its travel demand modeling process on a regular, on-going basis. In 2002, TPB staff chose to conduct a review of the modeling procedures using a panel from the Transportation Research Board (TRB). In more recent years, TPB staff has hired a consultant to provide that review. Both efforts are described below.

Transportation Research Board (TRB) Review

At its April 17, 2002 meeting, the TPB approved a process for conducting a review of the region's travel modeling procedures. The process called for the TPB to engage a respected non-partisan organization, such as the TRB, to appoint the members of the peer review panel and oversee the review process. A request was formally made to the TRB on May 8, 2002 in a letter from then TPB Chair, Phil Mendelson. The TRB accepted this task and began its analysis of the TPB modeling procedure in January 2003. On September 8, 2003 the TRB submitted its first letter report and on May 10, 2004 the TRB concluded its analysis with the submission to TPB of its second and final letter report. TPB staff provided detailed comments on each of the TRB reports in letters of September 8, 2003 and May 13, 2004 respectively.

The following materials document the TRB review and TPB staff comments:

• First letter report from TRB - September 8, 2003
• TPB staff comments on TRB first letter report of TPB models - September 8, 2003
• Descriptions of Proposed Work Elements for the TPB Models Development Program - December 24, 2003
• Appendices to Descriptions of Proposed Work Elements - December 24, 2003
• Second letter report from TRB - May 10, 2004
• TPB staff comments on TRB second letter report of TPB models - May 13, 2004

Scan of Best Practices in Travel Demand Forecasting

Beginning in 2005 (FY 2006), the TPB established a consultant-assisted project to assist with the development and application of the COG/TPB travel demand forecasting model. This project has been conducted using a series of one-year, task-order contracts and one-year contract extensions. Each contract has been designed so that it may be extended for up to two additional years, meaning that a consultant may hold the contract for up to three years before it needs to be re-bid. During FY 20 – FY 25, this project was put on pause due to the Gen3 Model development project that was contracted with Resource Systems Group, Inc. (RSG) and Baseline Mobility Group (BMG). With the completion of the Gen3 Model development in 2026, this project resumed in FY 26 following a Request for Proposal (RFP) for consultant assistance with travel demand forecasting methods used by the COG/TPB staff.

This model development consultant assistance project has frequently included focused research (or “scans”) on the modeling practices and methods used by other MPOs across the U.S. Consequently, the project has sometimes been referred to as the “scan of best modeling practice” project, or simply the “model scanning” project.

For fiscal years 2006-2008, the contract was awarded to Vanasse Hangen Brustlin, Inc. (VHB).  For fiscal years 2009-2011, the contract was awarded to Cambridge Systematics, Inc.  For fiscal years 2012-2014, the contract was awarded to AECOM. In FY 2015, the contract was awarded to Cambridge Systematics, Inc. In FY 2026, the contract was awarded to Resource Systems Group, Inc. (RSG) and Cambridge Systematics, Inc (CS). Some major documents that have been produced by the consultants in the past include:

• Cambridge Systematics, Inc. (CS) and Gallop Corporation:
  • Review of Consultant Recommendations from FY 2012-2014 of the COG/TPB Travel Demand Modeling Consultant-Assistance Project, Task Order 15.1. Final Report (October 15, 2015)
  • Identifying Potential Opportunities for Model Improvement, Task Order 15.2, Report 1 of 3. Final Report (October 15, 2015)
  • Status of Activity-Based Models and Dynamic Traffic Assignment at Peer MPOs, Task Order 15.2, Report 2 of 3. Final Report (October 15, 2015)
  • Strategic Plan for Model Development, Task Order 15.2, Report 3 of 3. Final Report (October 15, 2015)
  • Review of Transit Modeling with Respect to FTA Guidance, Task Order 15.3. Final Report (October 15, 2015)
  • Task Order 15.4, Modeling with Public Transport. Final Report (October 15, 2015)

• AECOM:
  • FY 2014 Final Report (August 18, 2014)​
  • Draft FY 2013 Final Report (July 1, 2013)
  • FY 2012 Final Draft Report (July 13, 2012)
• Cambridge Systematics, Inc. (CS):
  • Fiscal Year 2011 Task Reports, Final Report (June 30, 2011)
  • Fiscal Year 2010 Task Reports, Final Report (November 16, 2010)
  • Fiscal Year 2009 Task Reports, Final Report (November 20, 2009)
• Vanasse Hangen Brustlin, Inc. (VHB):
  • Expanded Evaluation of Peak Spreading (June 30, 2008)
  • Estimating the Impact of Exurban Commuters on Travel Demand (June 30, 2008)
  • Results of FY 2007 Travel Forecasting Research (November 16, 2007)
  • Results of FY 2006 Travel Forecasting Research (September 22, 2006)